The fresh new judge as well as unearthed that the city had a directly to getting supplied courtroom position so you can make use of their members’ full legal rights as a people, and this Paraguay’s constant refusal to recognize you to definitely standing is actually a citation of right
The fresh new Inter-American Payment for the Person Liberties alleged you to, by not respecting ancestral possessions liberties, the federal government of Paraguay endangered the fresh Yakye Axa Indigenous Community’s availability to help you restaurants, h2o and you can health care, and endurance into the ticket regarding Blogs cuatro (to life), 8 (directly to fair demo), 21 (straight to assets) and twenty-five (official defense) of Western Convention with the Peoples Liberties. New legal listed one to Paraguay try compelled to be the cause of the economic and you will personal services, unique susceptability, and you may standard laws, viewpoints and you may heritage out-of native peoples to help you efficiently cover him or her, and discovered you to definitely Paraguay’s decrease into the taking the newest Community’s leadership, legal condition and states land violated the brand new Community’s legal rights so you can official defense, a good trial, possessions, and finally a decent lives. As a result, new judge bought one to Paraguay deliver the People – “especially pupils, seniors and you can pregnant women” — with reparations, including compensation, food and water, sanitation, accessibility health care, and you will rightful label on their antique region.
The city said that the lack of entry to assets and you will palms of its area, and harmful this new endurance of the Community, lead to health, scientific and health susceptability to its professionals, resulting in, among other things, brand new death of expectant mothers, college students, plus the elderly. The courtroom discover Paraguay in ticket from Posts 3 (To Juridical Character), cuatro (To Lifetime), 5 (individual integrity), 8.step one (Trial), 19 (Liberties of your own Guy), 21 (Directly to Property) and twenty-five (Official Safety) of Summit, when it comes to the fresh debt established in Articles 1.step one (Obligations so you’re able to Regard Legal rights) and you will 2 (duty to take on domestic rules). The fresh judge bought Paraguay to engage in a series of reparation strategies, along with returning house with the Society, damages and you may efforts to not ever recite like make and assist the city with treatment. Among other procedures bought from the court, Paraguay should provide instantaneous “special care to help you women who try pregnant, both ahead of birth and when you look at the first days thereafter, therefore the newborn.”
The fresh legal indexed multiple specific types of threats encountered because of the lady of Community, together with era in which a lady was threatened by the a guy wielding good shotgun and something in which a lady is actually intimately exploited of the Condition professionals
This example inside issues within visibility out-of vulnerable people in native communities, for example people, expectant mothers, in addition to old. An effective petition is submitted up against Paraguay on behalf of the newest Sawhoyamaxa Local Community, alleging abuses from, among other things, the right to reasonable trial and you will judicial defense, the right to assets additionally the straight to life. This new petition noted why these violations put students, pregnant women and the earlier during the such as vulnerable facts. New Judge discovered Paraguay to stay pass away from Content 1(1), 2, 3, 4(1), 8, 19, 21 and twenty five of American Seminar toward Individual Liberties. The new Legal bought Paraguay to help you formally and you may in person convey to your Sawhoyamaxa the antique lands, to determine a community creativity financing, to expend low-pecuniary injuries, to provide the Sawhoyamaxa which have very first fundamentals up until the places was basically restored, to offer the Sawhoyamaxa to your called for products to own correspondence so you’re able to availableness fitness government, and to domestically 
enact legislation undertaking a method to own local organizations to recover their traditional lands.